Home Appliances

Narta CEO says JB Hi-Fi split was mutual as buying group prepares cost cuts

Yara CastellanosOctober 22, 20265 min read7 views

At a glance

  • Michael Jackson says Narta will remain number three collectively and must adjust its structure after JB Hi-Fi Group's departure.
  • Narta CEO Michael Jackson said JB Hi-Fi Group's decision to end its membership was mutually agreed and not caused by any dispute. He said Narta will remain number three collectively but will need cost and structural changes, including redundancies, while pushing members to use its services.
A conceptual illustration shows independent electronics and appliance stores linked to a central services hub, with larger retail towers in the background.

Narta chief executive Michael Jackson has publicly addressed JB Hi-Fi Group's decision to end its membership, describing the split as mutually agreed and saying it reflects the different strategic priorities of the two organisations.

In an interview, Jackson said Narta remained a substantial business without JB. He said core supplier purchases were well over $1 billion and that the group's members collectively represented more than 20 per cent of the consumer electronics, camera and home appliance market. Those figures, he argued, showed the value Narta offered suppliers, although he stressed that the organisation did more than aggregate buying.

Jackson said Narta was 61 years old and had been built to serve independent retailers. Its purpose, he said, was to give independent businesses collective scale so they could compete with major retailers. He noted that JB joined more than 25 years ago, when it had stores in Melbourne and Parramatta, and said Narta was proud to have been part of its growth into a large public company.

He also pointed to changes brought by JB's acquisition of The Good Guys and the later decision to bring that business into Narta. Jackson said the move added scale but created a significant imbalance across the membership. The COVID-19 period then overshadowed many of those underlying changes, he said, because the industry experienced several years of extraordinary growth and businesses focused on how well they were performing.

Jackson said the market was now different and that Narta had spent the past six months examining its responsibilities to shareholders and its full membership. He listed forecasting, stock visibility, end-of-life management, new model implementation, product content, training, predictive analytics, AI and automation among the services Narta provides beyond buying. Independent members, he said, needed those capabilities to compete with JB Hi-Fi, Harvey Norman, Bunnings, Woolworths, Big W, Costco and Amazon.

According to Jackson, JB agreed during discussions with Nick Wells that Narta had taken the right path over the past five to six years by investing in its service infrastructure. He said that without those investments, Narta could have struggled to meet its responsibilities to members. With JB leaving, he added, members now needed to engage with those services and work collectively.

Jackson said suppliers needed the independent channel to demonstrate efficiencies and a competitive cost to serve, and would challenge it if it could not. He said suppliers had told Narta that their cost to serve continued to increase, and that the economy, rising operating costs and market conditions affected them as much as retailers, so their expectations were higher. In the 24 hours since the announcement became public, he said, the response from suppliers had made him more confident; suppliers wanted a strong independent retail channel and understood the importance of choice, competition and balance in the market. He also noted that JB is a publicly listed company with four businesses — JB Hi-Fi Australia, JB Hi-Fi New Zealand, The Good Guys and e&s — and has its own strategic priorities.

He said there had been no event, incident or disagreement that caused JB Group to leave, nor had it been asked to leave. A few weeks before the announcement, he said, the two organisations mutually agreed that Narta should focus on its strategy and members while JB focused on its own priorities.

Without JB's scale, Narta will no longer be the largest buying group, Jackson said, but it will remain number three collectively. He acknowledged that the loss would affect income and operating costs. As a not-for-profit whose members contribute to running costs, Narta will need changes to its structure and cost base.

Jackson said difficult decisions would include redundancies and cost reductions across its board and executive structure, and that the impact on people could not be ignored. He said the priority was to keep Narta financially sustainable, retain the experience and capabilities needed to serve members and suppliers, and structure the organisation for the future. Narta's purpose, he said, had not changed: strengthening independent retail, which he said was needed more than ever.

Reported by Yara Castellanos, Cleaning and Indoor Air Analyst.